Faculty
Distinguished Teaching Professor
Josiah B. Gould Jr., Ph.D.
Johns Hopkins University
Professors
Robert C. Howell, Ph.D.
University of Michigan
John Kekes, Ph.D.
Australian National University
Robert G. Meyers, Ph.D.
State University of New York at Buffalo
William L. Reese, Ph.D.
University of Chicago
Bonnie Steinbock, Ph.D.
University of California, Berkeley
Kenneth Stern, Ph.D.
Yale University
Professor Emeritae/i
Robert F. Creegan, Ph.D.
Duke University
Berel Lang, Ph.D.
Columbia University
Thomas R. Martland, Ph.D.
Columbia University
Associate Professors
Robert M. Garvin, Ph.D.
Columbia University
Ronald A. McClamrock, Ph.D.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Harold Morick, Ph.D.
Columbia University
Anthony M. Ungar, Ph.D.
Stanford University
Naomi Zack, Ph.D.
Columbia University
Associate Professors Emeritae/i
Warder H. Cadbury, M.A.
Yale University
William V. Grimes, Ph.D.
University of North Carolina
Assistant Professors
Rachel Cohon, Ph.D.
University of California, Los Angeles
Jonathan Mandle, Ph.D.
University of Pittsburgh
Teaching Assistants (estimated): 10
The department offers diversified and
flexible programs leading to the B.A. and
M.A. degrees. A combined B.A./M.A. program is
available to qualified students. Through
lectures, seminars, tutorials, guided
research, undergraduate and graduate
colloquia, a student philosophy club,
interdisciplinary and special studies
programs, and visiting philosophers, a
challenging and balanced context for
philosophical development is provided for
major and nonmajor alike.
Careers
In pursuing philosophy, students develop
their ability to solve problems, communicate
effectively and organize ideas. Philosophy
majors are successfully employed in many
different areas of the private sector and
government serviceas managers,
administrators, journalists, etc.wherever a
liberal education combining analytical skills
with breadth of perspective is valued.
Holders of the bachelor's degree in
philosophy obtain jobs held by liberal arts
graduates in newspapers, government,
management, law, and computer-connected
businesses.
Degree Requirements for the Major in Philosophy
General Program B.A.:
Students are required to complete a minimum
of 36 credits in philosophy, no more than 6
of which may be at the 100 level. These
required credits must include: A Phi 110L or
110E*, 210L, 212L, 310, 312; an additional
upper division historical course from among
A Phi 311, 314, 315, 321, 329, 342, 344, 346,
442, 523, 524, 544, 546, 550, 552, 554, 556.
In their senior year, students are also
required to take A Phi 435 or 435Z.
* (A student may substitute A Phi 412 or
A Phi 416 for A Phi 110.)
Students are strongly urged to plan their
individual programs of study in consultation
with their advisers and in the light of their
interests and career goals.
Honors Program
The purpose of the honors program is to
provide well-qualified students with close
contact with faculty and fuller training in
philosophical research and writing than are
normally possible.
Students may be admitted in the second
semester of their sophomore year or during
their junior year. To be admitted, students
must have completed 12 credits of course work
from the Department of Philosophy. In
addition, students must have a cumulative
grade point average of 3.25 overall and 3.50
in philosophy. Students must submit evidence
of their written work, preferably a paper
written for a philosophy course. A
departmental honors committee administers the
program, admitting students and evaluating
their work.
Students are required to complete a minimum
of 42 credits. They must fulfill all regular
requirements for the major, and in addition,
take at least two 500-level courses in
philosophy (8 credits), and A Phi 498, Honors
Thesis (4 credits). The honors thesis is a
20-30 page essay, written in the senior year,
under the supervision of a faculty member in
the department, and acceptable to the
departmental honors committee.
Students are graduated "with honors in
philosophy" upon satisfactory completion of
the curricular requirements with a grade
point average of 3.50 in philosophy and a
minimum 3.25 overall.
Combined B.A./M.A. Program
The combined B.A./M.A. program in philosophy
provides an opportunity for students of
recognized academic ability and educational
maturity to fulfill integrated requirements
of undergraduate and master's degree programs
from the beginning of the junior year. A
carefully designed program can permit a
student to earn the B.A. and M.A. degrees
within nine semesters.
The combined program requires a minimum of
138 credits, of which at least 30 must be
graduate credits. In qualifying for the B.A.,
students must meet all University and college
requirements, including the requirements of
the undergraduate major described previously,
the minor requirement, the minimum 90-credit
liberal arts and sciences requirement,
general education requirements, and residency
requirements. In qualifying for the M.A.,
students must meet all University and college
requirements as outlined in the Graduate
Bulletin, including completion of a minimum
of 30 graduate credits, and any other
conditions such as a research seminar,
thesis, comprehensive examination, or other
professional experience and residency
requirements. Up to 12 graduate credits may
be applied simultaneously to both the B.A.
and M.A. programs.
Students are considered as undergraduates
until completion of 120 graduation credits
and satisfactory completion of all B.A.
requirements. Upon meeting B.A. requirements,
students are automatically considered as
graduate students.
Students may apply for admission to the
combined degree program in philosophy at the
beginning of their junior year or after the
successful completion of 56 credits, but no
later than the accumulation of 100 credits. A
cumulative grade point average of 3.20 or
higher and three supportive letters of
recommendation from faculty are required for
consideration.
The department offers diversified and
flexible programs leading to the B.A. and
M.A. degrees. A combined B.A./M.A. program is
available to qualified students. Through
lectures, seminars, tutorials, guided
research, undergraduate and graduate
colloquia, a student philosophy club,
interdisciplinary and special studies
programs, and visiting philosophers, a
challenging and balanced context for
philosophical development is provided for
major and nonmajor alike.
Courses
A Phi 110L Introduction to Philosophical Problems (3)
General Education: HA
Survey of representative problems in some of
the major areas of philosophy; topics such as
free will, morality, justice and social
order, knowledge and truth, God and religion,
art, and beauty. A Phi 110E is the writing
intensive version of A Phi 110L; only one may
be taken for credit.
A Phi 111 The Mind and the World (3)
A critical examination of contemporary topics
concerning the relation between the human
mind and natural world. The topics vary with
semesters, but typically include the state of
knowledge about the mind and its relationship
to the brain, the possibility of a science of
the mind, skepticism about knowledge, free
will and determinism, and the limits of
scientific knowledge.
A Phi 112L Critical Thinking (3)
General Education: HA
This is a course in informal logic. It
centers on the meaning of claims, and whether
a claim, should be accepted or rejected, or
whether suspension of judgment is
appropriate. This course is intended to help
students think clearly and effectively.
A Phi 114L Morals and Society (3)
General Education: HA
Philosophical study of the conflict between
personal values and the needs of society.
Topics include personal and social values,
the nature of moral reasoning, and ways to
resolve conflicts between values. Readings
from philosophers such as Plato, Aristotle,
Locke and Mill.
A Phi 115L Moral Choices (3)
General Education: HA
Critical examination of contemporary moral
problems in the light of the most influential
moral theories. The problems discussed vary
with semesters, but they typically include
such topics as abortion, affirmative action,
animals and the environment, capital
punishment, euthanasia, free speech and
censorship, liberty and paternalism, sex and
love, terrorism, and world hunger.
A Phi 116L (= A Rel 116L) World Views (3)
General Education: CHP & HA
Examination of some of the major systems of
assumptions and values humans have used in
attempting to understand reality, the meaning
of life, and their dealings with others.
World views studied may vary from semester to
semester. Examples are Greek, Judeo-
Christian, Marxist and libertarian. Only one
of A Phi 116L & A Rel 116L may be taken for
credit.
A Phi 199Z Writing in Philosophy (1)
General Education: WI
A student enrolled in a 100- or 200-level
philosophy course may, with the consent of
the instructor of that course, fulfill a
writing intensive version of it by
registering concurrently for A Phi 199Z. The
instructor will assign the student written
work in addition to that required for the
companion course and will meet with him or
her over the course of the semester to
discuss this work. (A student who
subsequently withdraws from the companion
course will also be dropped from A Phi 199Z.)
Corequisite(s): concurrent registration in a
100- or 200-level philosophy course. S/U
graded.
A Phi 210L Introduction to Logic (3)
General Education: HA
Introduction to classical and modern logic
with an emphasis on the theory and
application of truth functions. Introduction
to quantification; discussion of the
structure and properties of formal systems of
logic. Students should be prepared to do
daily homework assignments.
A Phi 212L Introduction to Ethical Theory (3)
General Education: HA
Introduction to the dimensions of ethical
experience, the factors in value judgments,
and alternative theories and methods of
reasoning about such notions as right and
wrong, obligations, moral codes, moral
conflicts and responsibility.
A Phi 214 (= A Rel 214) World Religions (3)
General Education: CHP & HD
Survey of the major religions of the world,
concentrating on those practices and beliefs
that contribute to their value systems.
Religions include Buddhism, Christianity,
Confucianism, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism and
Taoism. Only one of A Phi 214 & A Rel 214 may
be taken for credit.
A Phi 216 Existentialist Values (3)
Philosophical study of existentialism as a
cultural movement of protest, criticism and
vision, concentrating on its interpretation
of the ethical good. Readings such as Pascal,
Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, Dostoevsky, Unamuno,
Kafka, de Beauvoir and Tillich. May not be
offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 218L Understanding Science (3)
General Education: HA
Introduction to problems of scientific
reasoning such as: the nature of scientific
method, hypothetical-deductive testing of
hypotheses, fallacies of testing, and the
relevance of science to society and religion.
Examples drawn from the physical and social
sciences. A Phi 112L or 210L recommended.
A Phi 240 Special Topics in Philosophy (1-4)
Study of a selected topic in philosophy. May
be repeated with different topics. Consult
class schedule for specific topic. May not be
offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 301 (= A Lin 301 & A Psy 301) Introduction to Cognitive Science (3)
Cognitive science investigates the nature of
the human mind and cuts across several
disciplines (e.g., psychology, computer
science, philosophy, linguistics). This
course examines the approaches these
disciplines use to promote our understanding
of various mental phenomena (e.g.,
perceiving, reasoning, production and
comprehension of language, memory.) Only one
of A Lin 301, A Phi 301 & A Psy 301 may be
taken for credit. May not be offered during
1999-2000.
A Phi 310 Ancient Philosophy (3)
The philosophies of representative thinkers
of the West from the pre-Socratics to
Plotinus. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-
level course in philosophy.
A Phi 311 History of Medieval Philosophy (3)
The philosophies of representative thinkers
of the West from Plotinus to Descartes.
Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-level course
in philosophy. May not be offered during
1999-2000.
A Phi 312 Seventeenth- and Eighteenth-Century Philosophy (3)
The development of modern thought from its
medieval and Renaissance background,
concentrating on some of the principal
European philosophies from Descartes through
Kant. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-level
course in philosophy.
A Phi 314 History of Nineteenth-Century Philosophy (3)
The philosophies of some representative
continental, British, and American thinkers
from the Kantian period to the end of the
century. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-level
course in philosophy.
A Phi 315 Twentieth-Century Philosophy (3)
Contrasting philosophical movements in the
20th century, emphasizing divergent
tendencies in the United States, Britain and
on the European continent. Prerequisite(s): a
100- or 200-level course in philosophy.
A Phi 320 Political and Social Philosophy (3)
The philosophical bases for social and
political institutions and practices. Such
issues as the following: the nature of the
state, justice and law, rights and natural
rights, equality, social utility and public
interest. A Phi 320Z is the writing intensive
version of A Phi 320; only one may be taken
for credit. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-level
course in philosophy. May not be
offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 321 Seventeenth-Nineteenth-Century Ethical Theory (3)
Historical and critical study of some ethical
theories selected from the period beginning
with Hobbes and ending with Kant.
Prerequisite(s): a 100 or 200-level course in
philosophy. May not be offered during 1999-
2000.
A Phi 322 (= A Rel 322) Philosophy of Religion (3)
Philosophical analysis of selected religious
concepts and programs, based upon the
writings of representative philosophers and
theologians. Focuses on Judeo-Christian
tradition. Only one of A Phi 322 & A Rel 322
may be taken for credit. Prerequisite(s): a
100- or 200-level course in philosophy. May
not be offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 324 Philosophy of Art (3)
Philosophical analysis of concepts and
sentiments pertaining to creation,
appreciation and criticism of the arts in the
generic sense of the semester.
Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-level course
in philosophy. May not be offered during
1999-2000.
A Phi 325 Philosophy of Law (3)
The nature and function of law, the relation
of law to morality, standards of judicial
reasoning and the limits of law.
Prerequisite(s): junior or senior class
standing and one course in philosophy. May
not be offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 327 Philosophy and Psychoanalysis (3)
An investigation of the philosophical
significance of Freud's account of mind,
conscience, art, religion, love and
aggression, masculinity and femininity, among
other things. Freud, Sartre, Wittgenstein and
Habermas are among those writers to be read.
Prerequisite(s): junior or senior class
standing and one course in philosophy. May
not be offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 328 Philosophy and Race (3)
General Education: HD
A philosophical analysis of fundamental
concepts of race and ethnicity in the social
sciences, physical sciences, public policy,
and ordinary life. Questions will include:
What is a race? What is racism? What is a
racial identity? Does everyone need a racial
identity? A Phi 328Z is the writing intensive
version of A Phi 328; only one may be taken
for credit. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-
level course in philosophy. May not be
offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 329 American Philosophy Since 1860 (3)
Survey of the main figures in American
philosophy, concentrating on Peirce, James,
Royce, Dewey and Santayana. Topics include
pragmatism and evolution, idealism and
naturalism, and theories about the nature of
religion. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-
level course in Philosophy. May not be
offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 332 Quantification Theory (3)
An introduction to first-order quantification
theory, emphasizing formal properties of
arguments rather than their role in everyday
discourse. Topics will include the syntax and
semantics of first-order languages,
derivations and counter-examples, theories of
identity and description and, perhaps, some
elementary meta-theory. Prerequisite(s): Phi
210L or permission of instructor.
A Phi 336 Existentialist Philosophies (3)
Existentialist thinking approached through
the writings of representative authors such
as Heidegger, Sartre, Jaspers and Merleau-
Ponty. A Phi 336Z is the writing-intensive
version of A Phi 336; only one may be taken
for credit. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-
level course in philosophy.
A Phi 338 Moral Problems in Medicine (3)
An investigation of moral problems in
medicine, such as the health professional-patient
relationship, medical paternalism,
informed consent, social justice and health
policy, the treatment of severely defective
newborns, and the withholding of life-prolonging
treatment. Prerequisite(s): junior
or senior class standing, and permission of
instructor. May not be offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 340 Topics in Philosophy (1-4)
Problems selected on the basis of faculty and
student interest. May be taken more than once
with different content. Consult fall and
spring schedules for specific topics.
Prerequisite(s): a 100- or 200-level course
in philosophy. May not be offered during
1999-2000.
A Phi 342 (= A Rel 342) Indian Philosophies (3)
Introduction to Indian philosophies from pre-Vedic
India to contemporary thought. Only one
of A Phi 342 & A Rel 342 may be taken for
credit. Prerequisite(s): A Phi 214 or A His
176 or A His 177 (or 177Z), or junior or
senior class standing. May not be offered
during 1999-2000.
A Phi 344 (= A Eac 344 & A Rel 344) Chinese Philosophies (3)
Introduction to Chinese philosophies from the
Chou period to contemporary thought. Only one
of A Phi 344, A Eac 344 & A Rel 344 may be
taken for credit. Prerequisite(s): A Phi 214
or A Eac 170 or A His 176 or A His 177 (or
177Z); or junior or senior class standing.
A Phi 346 (= A Rel 346) Japanese Religions and Philosophies (3)
Introduction to Japanese philosophies and
religions from the pre-Buddhist period to
contemporary Japan. Only one of A Phi 346 and
A Rel 346 may be taken for credit.
Prerequisite(s): A Phi 214 or A His 176 or
A His 177( or 177Z), or junior or senior
class standing.
A Phi 350 (= A Wss 350) Philosophy and Feminism (3)
Examination of the theories of the oppression
of women and proposals for solutions.
Particular attention will be paid to
existentialism, biological determinism,
Marxism and feminist psychology and
epistemology. Only one of A Phi 350 and A Wss
350 may be taken for credit. Prerequisite(s):
one course in philosophy or women's studies.
May not be offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 360 Philosophy and Literature (3)
The study, through philosophical and literary
texts, of the relation between philosophy and
literature: philosophy in literature,
philosophy as literature, and the philosophy
of literature. Prerequisite(s): a 100- or
200-level course in philosophy. May not be
offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 399Z Writing in Philosophy (1)
General Education: WI
A student enrolled in a 300- or 400-level
philosophy course may, with the consent of
the instructor of that course, fulfill a
writing intensive version of it by
registering concurrently for A Phi 399Z. The
instructor will assign the student written
work in addition to that required for the
companion course and will meet with him or
her over the course of the semester to
discuss this work. (A student who
subsequently withdraws from the companion
course will also be dropped from A Phi 399Z.)
Corequisite(s): concurrent registration in a
300- or 400-level philosophy course. S/U
graded.
A Phi 410 Perspectives on Reasoning (3)
The major philosophical questions that arise
in connection with reasoning in general. Are
there distinctively different kinds of
reasoning in different subject matters? Is
reasoning relative or absolute?
Prerequisite(s): A Phi 112L, 210L, 218L; or
permission of instructor. May not be offered
during 1999-2000.
A Phi 412 Metaphysics (3)
A systematic examination of such
philosophical concepts as existence, essence,
causality, purpose, value, mind, freedom and
unity. Prerequisite(s): A Phi 210L and a 300-
level course in philosophy.
A Phi 415 Philosophy of Language (3)
The structure and properties of language with
regard to philosophical issues. Examines such
issues as meaning, reference, analyticity,
truth and psychoanalytic dream interpretation
in the context of the contemporary theories
of meaning and linguistic structure.
Prerequisite(s): A Phi 210L and a 300-level
course in philosophy; or permission of
instructor. May not be offered during 1999-
2000.
A Phi 416 Philosophy of Mind (3)
A systematic discussion of various
contemporary and historically important
issues concerning mind: classical theories of
mind and body, including dualisms,
materialism, double-aspect theories and
functionalism; cognitive science and
theoretical linguistics; artificial
intelligence; and the nature of belief,
desire, intention and other psychological
notions. Prerequisite(s): A Phi 210L and a
300-level course in philosophy, or permission
of instructor.
A Phi 418 Philosophy of Science (3)
Basic issues in philosophy of science, such
as the nature of laws and theories,
verifiability and confirmation, explanation
and prediction, statistics and probability.
Prerequisite(s): A Phi 210L and a 300-level
course in philosophy; or permission of
instructor.
A Phi 422 Theory of Knowledge (3)
Systematic study of theories of knowledge,
including such topics as theories of
perception, the character and value of
logical systems, theories of the nature of
truth and of the nature of proof
Prerequisite(s): A Phi 210L and a 300-level
course in philosophy; or permission of
instructor. May not be offered during 1999-
2000.
A Phi 423 The Skeptical Tradition (3)
Examination of the skeptical tradition from
the ancient Greeks to the present. The focus
will be on the arguments for thinking
knowledge is impossible. Topics include
skepticism as a way of life, Hume's
skepticism, religious skepticism, common-
sense philosophy, and the relation between
knowledge and certainty. Prerequisite(s):
A Phi 210L and a 300-level course in
philosophy. May not be offered during 1999-
2000.
A Phi 425 Contemporary Ethical Theory (3)
Selected normative and meta-ethical theories,
with emphasis on issues of interest in
contemporary discussions of values and the
nature of valuation. Prerequisite(s): A Phi
212L and a 300-level course in philosophy.
A Phi 432 Completeness and Decidability (3)
An introduction to the meta-theory of first-order
logic. Topics will include the
completeness theorem and its corollaries, as
well as a discussion of questions concerning
the undecidability of validity.
Prerequisite(s): A Phi 332 or permission of
instructor.
A Phi 435 The Nature of Philosophy (3)
Critical and historical study of alternate
philosophical theories about the nature,
purpose, justification and rationality of
philosophy. Open to philosophy majors in
their senior year or by permission of
instructor.
A Phi 442 Phenomenology (3)
Examination of historical and conceptual
development of phenomenology in the 20th
century, starting with Husserl's
"presuppositionless and purely descriptive
science of the structures of consciousness",
including works by Sartre, Heidegger, and
Merleau-Ponty. Emphasis on (a) the idea of a
presuppositionless account of consciousness;
(b) the motivations for and nature of the
"existential turn"; and (c) connections
between phenomenology and both analytic
philosophy and scientific psychology.
Prerequisite(s): junior or senior class
standing or permission of instructor. May not
be offered during 1999-2000.
A Phi 474 Society and Values (3)
Critical study of ethical and/or political
concepts, such as freedom, equality,
happiness, duty, rights, virtue, or theories,
such as liberalism, pluralism,
consequentialism, deontology, and virtue
theory through the examination of historical
and contemporary works. Prerequisite(s):
A Phi 212 and a 300-level course in
Philosophy, or permission of instructor.
A Phi 497 Independent Study and Research (1-4)
Guided research and writing on a selected
problem in philosophy on a tutorial basis.
May be repeated more than once with different
content. Prerequisite(s): a 300-level course
in philosophy and the approval of the
individual faculty member acting as project
supervisor and of the departmental
Undergraduate Studies Committee.
A Phi 498 Honors Thesis in Philosophy (4)
Independent honors thesis written under the
direction of an appropriate faculty member,
and received and evaluated by the Honors
Committee. Prerequisite(s): Admission to the
Honors Program in Philosophy.